Menus
- Dinner
- Wine By The Glass
- Happy Hour
- Hand-Crafted Cocktails
- Beer List
- Spirits
- Late Night Menu (Fri - Sat 10pm - 12am)
DAILY SPECIALS
FOR THE TABLE
-
Artisanal Cheese
local honey, fruit compote, toasted baguette
$20
-
Charcuterie
whole grain mustard, cornichons, toasted baguette
$20
-
Artisanal Cheese & Charcuterie
chef's selection, rotating, all the accompaniments
$30
-
Roasted Heirloom Tomato Flatbread
Add meat: serrano..8 speck...6 chorizo..5
$11
-
Braised Short Rib Flatbread
pesto, mozzarella & watercress
$18
-
Smoked Chicken Flatbread
roasted pear, pickled shallot, gorgonzola, baby arugula, saba
$18
-
Momma Mia Oysters
A nice medium brine with a slightly fruity finish
$4
-
Custom Cheese & Charcuterie
Custom cheese and charcuterie boards, made exactly how you want them.
STARTERS
-
Beef Carpaccio
caper raisin emulsion, pickled beech mushrooms, shaved mimolette, sherry vinaigrette
$20
-
Jamón Mangalica
heirloom tomato carpaccio, parmesan reggiano, aged balsamic, watercress
$24
-
Pei Mussels
coconut curry, caramelized tomato and onion, toasted baguette
$16
-
Oyster Rockefeller
4 Momma Mia PEI oysters, pernod spinach cream, pancetta, herbed bread crumbs
$20
-
Seared Foie Gras
brioche, poached pear, pine nut pudding, duck fat snow
$22
-
Chicken Marsala Meatballs
Joyce Farms chicken, pecorino, bacon
$15
-
Crispy Pork Belly
lentil braised pork ragout, soy glaze, spiced carrot purée, black garlic purée
$22
-
Charred Octopus (GF)
summer panzenella, 'nduja vinaigrette, black olive puree
$21
SALAD
-
Insalata Mista (GF)
artichokes, prosciutto, roasted peppers, creamy feta, roasted garlic balsamic
$16
-
Avocado & Fennel Salad (GF)
shaved fennel, arugula, apple, manchego, green goddess
-
Bibb Salad
green goddess, pickled shallot, crispy egg, marcona almonds
-
Burrata
marinated heirloom tomato, local greens, arugula pesto, roasted pear, balsamic reduction
$17
MAINS
-
Braised Short Ribs (GF)
pomme puree, roasted beech mushrooms, rosemary jus
$38
-
Herb-Crusted Lamb Loin
house-made goat cheese, stuffed beet root tortelli, cauliflower purée, sherry jus
$42
-
Pappardelle Bolognese
house-made pasta, beef & pork ragout, pecorino
$29
-
Duck Breast (GF)
lentils, baby carrots, parsnip puree, orange glaze
$40
-
Faroe Island Salmon (GF)
sunchoke textures, caper raisin emulsion, miso espuma
$36
-
Niman Ranch Pork Osso Buco
parmesan polenta, pickled apple slaw, spiced jus
$34
-
Red Snapper
summer corn risotto, parmesan nage, roasted corn & tomato salad
$40
-
Scallop Carbonara
bacon fat & black pepper tagliatelle, pancetta, peas, confit egg yolk
$34
-
Caveman Burger
Aged cheddar, bacon jam, special sauce, side greens
$21
SIDES
-
Summer Corn Risotto (GF)
charred corn fresh herbs
$16
-
Crispy Truffled Fingerling Potatoes (GF)
Truffle aioli, shaved pec, fresh herbs
$13
-
Crispy Sunchokes & Artichokes
Bagna càuda vinaigrette, fennel pollen
$14
-
Mushrooms Under Glass
forest mushrooms, brioche house made truffle ricotta, parmesan cream, rosemary "smoke"
$16
Sparkling
-
Zonin
Prosecco, Italy
187 mL $11
-
J.P. Chenet
Brut Rose Sparkling, France
187 mL $13
-
Mas Fi Cava
Old World Brut, Spain
187 mL $15
White Wines
-
2019 Montagne Silicieuse
Sancerre, Loire Valley, FR
6 oz. $16
9 oz. $24
-
2020 Andis "Cuvee Blanc"
White Blend, Amador, CA
6 oz. $12
9 oz. $18
-
2018 Ca Di Ponti
Pinot Grigio, Pavia, IT
6 oz. $9
9 oz. $14
-
2018 Kracher
Pinot Gris, Burgenland, Austria
6 oz. $13
9 oz. $19
-
2019 Round Pond
Sauvignon Blanc, Napa, CA
6 oz. $14
9 oz. $21
-
2019 The Loop
Sauvignon Blanc, New Zealand
6 oz. $12
9 oz. $18
-
2019 Balleto Unoaked
Chardonnay, RRV, CA
6 oz. $14
9 oz. $21
-
2017 Sanglier
Chardonnay, Sonoma
6 oz. $14
9 oz. $21
-
2019 Raeburn
Chardonnay, RRV
6 oz. $13
9 oz. $19
Rosé Wines
-
2019 Chehalem
Pinot Noir, Willamette Valley, OR
6 oz. $12
9 oz. $18
-
2019 Lago Cerqueira
Vinho Verde Rosé, Portugal
6 oz. $9
9 oz. $14
-
2019 Cinsault, Mont Gravet
Pays D'OC France
6 oz. $9
9 oz. $14
Red Wines
-
2016 Les Charmes de la Grange
Bordeaux, France
6 oz. $13
9 oz. $19
-
2019 Bodega Grazon
Marselan, Maldonado, Uruguay
6 oz. $12
9 oz. $18
-
2018 Baracchi "O'llilo"
Tuscany, Italy
6 oz. $12
9 oz. $18
-
2019 GC "Commuter"
Pinot Noir, Willamette, OR
6 oz. $14
9 oz. $21
-
2018 Folktale "Estate"
Pinot Noir, CA
6 oz. $16
9 oz. $24
-
2017 Bouchaine Estate
Pinot Noir, Napa Valley, CA
6 oz. $18
9 oz. $27
-
2018 Raffy "Hedera"
Malbec, Mendoza, Argentina
6 oz. $14
9 oz. $21
-
2017 Inkblot by Michael David
Petit Verdot, Lodi, CA
6 oz. $18
9 oz. $27
-
2019 Aerena by Aaron Pott
Cabernet Sauvignon, Red Hills, CA
6 oz. $14
9 oz. $21
-
2018 Swanson Vineyards
Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa
6 oz. $18
9 oz. $27
-
2018 Blackboard
Red Blend, Columbia Valley, WA
6 oz. $14
9 oz. $21
-
2017 Numanthia "Termes"
Red Blend, Spain
6 oz. $16
9 oz. $24
DAILY HAPPY HOUR
MONDAY - SATURDAY
4pm - 6pm
REVERSE HAPPY HOUR
FRIDAY - SATURDAY
10pm - 12am
Drinks
-
Select Beer
$4
-
The Classics
Negroni, Old Fashioned, Margarita, Moscow Mule, Gin Basil Smash, Bee's Knees
$8
-
House Red, White, Rose Wines
pinot grigio, chardonnay, pinot noir, cabernet sauvignon, rosé
$6
-
Caveman-hattin
Rittenhouse Rye, Cocchi di Torino, Dry Curacao, Vanilla Infused Angostura
$8
-
Liquid Gold
Tromba Blanco Tequila, Ancho Reyes Chili Poblano, Yellow Bell Pepper, Basil, Lemon
$9
Bites
-
Chicken Marsala Meatballs
$8
-
Crispy Brandade Cakes
$12
-
Roasted Heirloom Tomato Flatbread
$8
-
Prince Edward Island Thai Mussels
$9
-
Tasso Grilled Cheese French Onion Dipper
$12
-
Mediterranean Mixed Olives
$6
-
Momma Mia Oysters with Pomegranate-Yuzu Foam
$12
CAVE FAVORITES
-
Catacomb
Mezcal, Aperol, Yellow Chartreuse, Habanero Honey, Peach, Lime
$15
-
Pitch Black
Four Roses Bourbon, Montenegro, Mr. Black Coffee Liqueur, Japanese Black Tea Syrup, Lemon, Squid Ink
$15
-
Liquid Gold
Tromba Blanco Tequila, Ancho Reyes Chili Poblano, Yellow Bell Pepper, Basil, Lemo
$15
-
Hidden Gem
Empress Violette Gin, St. Germain, Honey, Lemon, Egg Whites
$15
-
Caveman-Hattan
Rittenhouse Rye, Cocchi di Torino, Dry Curacao, Vanilla Infused Angostura
$15
-
High Maintenance
Hibiscus Infused Vodka, Housemade Watermelon Cordial, Aperitivo Nonino, Lemon
$15
-
Treasurita
Lunazul Reposado Tequila, House Blood Orange Cordial, Lime, Grand Marnier Foam
$15
-
Bootlegger's Rum Blend
Secret Recipe...Shhh! Daiquiri - $2 Extra Bootlegger's Rum, Demerara, Lime
$15
SEASONAL FEATURES
Seasonal Cocktails For Fall / Winter Coming Soon!Bottle / Can
-
Miller Light
4.2% ABV
$6
-
Yuengling Lager
4.4% ABV
$7
-
Bonehook "Wicked Seas" Hazy IPA
6.8% ABV
$8
-
Fort Myers "Gateway Gold" Blonde Ale
$7
-
Michelob Ultra
4.2% ABV
$5
-
Stella Artois
5% ABV
$6
-
Barrel of Monks "Wizard" Witbier
$7
-
Islamorada "No Wake Zone" Ale
$7
-
Keewaydin Crusher Cream Ale
$6
-
Fort Myers Brewing Chocolate Peanut Butter Porter
$8
-
Omission Gluten-Free Lager
$7
-
Beck’s Non-Alcoholic
$5
Click below for our full spirits list!
Highly Allocated Selections, prices subject to change.
Download PDFRye Whiskey
-
Angels Envy
$24
-
Basil Hayden Carib RSV
$14
-
Clyde Mays
$11
-
High West Double Rye
$11
-
Kentucky Owl Rye #2
$48
-
Mastersons 10 yr. Rye
$20
-
Michters Single Barrel
$12
-
Redemption
$10
-
Sazerac Rye
$10
-
Thomas Handy Rye
$54
-
Whistlepig "Piggyback"
$11
-
Whistlepig 10 yr.
$22
-
Whistlepig 12 yr.
$32
-
Whistlepig 15 yr.
$50
-
Whistlepig “Bosshog”
$125
Bourbon
-
1792 Full Proof
$16
-
1972 Single Barrel
$14
-
1972 Small Batch
$12
-
Angel’s Envy
$14
-
Basil Hayden’s
$14
-
Blanton’s
$45
-
Buffalo Trace
$10
-
Calumet Farms
$14
-
Chicken Cock KY Straight
$16
-
Eagle Rare
$15
-
Elijah Craig
$13
-
Elmer T. Lee
$65
-
E.H. Taylor Small Batch
$13
-
E.H. Taylor Single Barrel
$22
-
E.H. Taylor Four Grains
$45
-
Four Roses Small Batch
$11
-
Garrison Brothers
$18
-
Garrison Bros. Single Barrel
$26
-
High West American Prairie
$11
-
Maker’s Mark
$11
-
Maker’s Mark 46
$15
-
Old Ezra 7 Year
$16
-
Old Rip Van Winkle 10yr.
$65
-
George T Stagg
$85
-
Stagg JR
$35
-
Wild Turkey “Longbranch”
$11
-
Wild Turkey Master’s Keep
$39
-
Wilderness Trail Single Barrel
$20
-
Wilderness Trail Small Batch
$20
-
Woodford Reserve
$12
-
Yellow Stone Ltd KY
$26
-
Roasted Heirloom Tomato
$11
-
Smoked Chicken
roasted pear, pickled shallot, gorgonzola, baby arugula, saba
$18
-
Short Rib
mozzarella, watercress
$18
-
Burrata Salad
marinated heirloom tomato, local greens, arugula pesto, roasted pear, balsamic reduction
$17
-
Caveman Burger
aged cheddar, bacon jam, special sauce, side greens
$21
-
Pei Mussels
coconut curry, caramelized tomato and onion, toasted baguette
$16
-
Chicken Marsala Meatballs
Joyce Farms chicken, parmesan, bacon, wild mushrooms
$15
-
Artisanal Cheese
local honey, fruit compote, toasted baguette
$20
-
Charcuterie
whole grain mustard, cornichon, toasted baguette
$20
-
Custom Cheese & Charcuterie
Build your own board exactly how you want it
-
Artisanal Cheese & Charcuterie
$30