Menus

Beet Salad

whipped burrata, greens, seasonal fruit, red wine vinaigrette

$17
Crispy Pork Belly

sweet potato puree, spiced jus, florida orange segments

$20
Seared Scallops

vegetable succotash, corn purée, lemon brown butter sauce

$36

Artisanal Cheese

local honey, fruit compote, toasted baguette

$20
Charcuterie

whole grain mustard, cornichons, toasted baguette

$20
Artisanal Cheese & Charcuterie

chef's selection, rotating, all the accompaniments

$30
Roasted Heirloom Tomato Flatbread

$11
Braised Short Rib Flatbread

pesto, mozzarella & watercress

$18
Smoked Chicken Flatbread

roasted pear, pickled shallot, gorgonzola, baby arugula, saba

$18
Momma Mia Oysters

A nice medium brine with a slightly fruity finish

$4
Custom Cheese & Charcuterie

Custom cheese and charcuterie boards, made exactly how you want them.

Beef Carpaccio

caper raisin emulsion, pickled beech mushrooms, shaved mimolette, sherry vinaigrette

$20
Jamón Mangalica

heirloom tomato carpaccio, parmesan reggiano, aged balsamic, watercress

$24
Pei Mussels

coconut curry, caramelized tomato and onion, toasted baguette

$16
Oyster Rockefeller

4 Momma Mia PEI oysters, pernod spinach cream, pancetta, herbed bread crumbs

$20
Seared Foie Gras

brioche, poached pear, pine nut pudding, duck fat snow

$22
Chicken Marsala Meatballs

Joyce Farms chicken, pecorino, bacon

$15
Short Rib Raviolo

wild mushrooms, black truffle cream, parmesan

$20
Charred Octopus (GF)

summer panzenella, 'nduja vinaigrette, black olive puree

$21

Insalata Mista (GF)

artichokes, prosciutto, roasted peppers, creamy feta, roasted garlic balsamic

$16
Avocado & Fennel Salad (GF)

shaved fennel, arugula, apple, manchego, green goddess
Bibb Salad

green goddess, pickled shallot, crispy egg, marcona almonds
Burrata

marinated heirloom tomato, local greens, arugula pesto, roasted pear, balsamic reduction

$17

Braised Short Ribs (GF)

pomme puree, roasted beech mushrooms, rosemary jus

$38
Herb-Crusted Lamb Loin

house-made goat cheese, stuffed beet root tortelli, cauliflower purée, sherry jus

$42
Pappardelle Bolognese

house-made pasta, beef & pork ragout, pecorino

$29
Duck Breast (GF)

lentils, baby carrots, parsnip puree, orange glaze

$40
Faroe Island Salmon (GF)

sunchoke textures, caper raisin emulsion, miso espuma

$36
Niman Ranch Pork Osso Buco

parmesan polenta, pickled apple slaw, spiced jus

$34
Red Snapper

summer corn risotto, parmesan nage, roasted corn & tomato salad

$40
Scallop Carbonara

bacon fat & black pepper tagliatelle, pancetta, peas, confit egg yolk

$34
Caveman Burger

Aged cheddar, bacon jam, special sauce, side greens

$21

Summer Corn Risotto (GF)

charred corn fresh herbs

$16
Crispy Truffled Fingerling Potatoes (GF)

Truffle aioli, shaved pec, fresh herbs

$13
Crispy Sunchokes & Artichokes

Bagna càuda vinaigrette, fennel pollen

$14
Mushrooms Under Glass

forest mushrooms, brioche house made truffle ricotta, parmesan cream, rosemary "smoke"

$16

2019 Montagne Silicieuse

Sancerre, Loire Valley, FR

6 oz. $16

9 oz. $24
2020 Andis "Cuvee Blanc"

White Blend, Amador, CA

6 oz. $12

9 oz. $18
2018 Ca Di Ponti

Pinot Grigio, Pavia, IT

6 oz. $9

9 oz. $14
2018 Kracher

Pinot Gris, Burgenland, Austria

6 oz. $13

9 oz. $19
2019 Long Meadow Ranch

Sauvignon Blanc, Napa, CA

6 oz. $14

9 oz. $21
2019 The Loop

Sauvignon Blanc, New Zealand

6 oz. $12

9 oz. $18
2019 Balleto Unoaked

Chardonnay, RRV, CA

6 oz. $14

9 oz. $21
2017 Sanglier

Chardonnay, Sonoma

6 oz. $14

9 oz. $21
2019 Raeburn

Chardonnay, RRV

6 oz. $13

9 oz. $19

2019 Chehalem

Pinot Noir, Willamette Valley, OR

6 oz. $12

9 oz. $18
2019 Lago Cerqueira

Vinho Verde Rosé, Portugal

6 oz. $9

9 oz. $14
2019 Cinsault, Mont Gravet

Pays D'OC France

6 oz. $9

9 oz. $14

2016 Les Charmes de la Grange

Bordeaux, France

6 oz. $13

9 oz. $19
2020 Barista Wine Co.

Pinotage, West Cape, SA

6 oz. $12

9 oz. $18
2018 Baracchi "O'llilo"

Tuscany, Italy

6 oz. $12

9 oz. $18
2019 GC "Commuter"

Pinot Noir, Willamette, OR

6 oz. $14

9 oz. $21
2017 Bouchaine Estate

Pinot Noir, Napa Valley, CA

6 oz. $18

9 oz. $27
2018 Big Basin "Dune & Mtn."

Pinot Noir, CA

6 oz. $13

9 oz. $19
2018 Raffy "Hedera"

Malbec, Mendoza, Argentina

6 oz. $14

9 oz. $21
2017 Inkblot by Michael David

Petit Verdot, Lodi, CA

6 oz. $18

9 oz. $27
2019 Aerena by Aaron Pott

Cabernet Sauvignon, Red Hills, CA

6 oz. $14

9 oz. $21
2018 Swanson Vineyards

Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa

6 oz. $18

9 oz. $27
2018 Blackboard

Red Blend, Columbia Valley, WA

6 oz. $14

9 oz. $21
2017 Numanthia "Termes"

Red Blend, Spain

6 oz. $16

9 oz. $24

Select Beer

$4
The Classics

Negroni, Old Fashioned, Margarita, Moscow Mule, Gin Basil Smash, Bee's Knees

$8
House Red, White, Rose Wines

pinot grigio, chardonnay, pinot noir, cabernet sauvignon, rosé

$6
Caveman-hattin

Rittenhouse Rye, Cocchi di Torino, Dry Curacao, Vanilla Infused Angostura

$8
Liquid Gold

Tromba Blanco Tequila, Ancho Reyes Chili Poblano, Yellow Bell Pepper, Basil, Lemon

$9

Short Rib Raviolo

$10
Chicken Marsala Meatballs

$8
Roasted Heirloom Tomato Flatbread

$8
Prince Edward Island Thai Mussels

$9
Mediterranean Mixed Olives

$6

Caveman-Hattan

Rittenhouse Rye, Cocchi di Torino, Dry Curacao, Vanilla Infused Angostura

$15
Treasurita

Lunazul Reposado Tequila, House Blood Orange Cordial, Lime, Grand Marnier Foam

$15
Pitch Black

Four Roses Bourbon, Montenegro, Mr. Black Coffee Liqueur, Japanese Black Tea Syrup, Lemon, Squid Ink

$15
Hidden Gem

Empress Violette Gin, St. Germain, Lemon, Egg Whites

$15
Catacomb

Reposado Mezcal, Aperol, Yellow Chartreuse, Habanero Honey, Peach, Lime

$15
Bootlegger's Rum Blend

Secret Recipe...Shhh! Daiquiri - $2 Extra Bootlegger's Rum, Demerara, Lime

$15
Liquid Gold

Tromba Blanco Tequila, Ancho Reyes Chili Poblano, Yellow Bell Pepper, Basil, Lemo

$15

The Guactail!

Blanco Tequila, Avocado, Jalapeño, Pineapple, Lime

$15
High Maintenance

Hibiscus Infused Vodka, Housemade Watermelon Cordial, Aperitivo Nonino, Lemon

$15
Smooth Moves

Pisco, Passionfruit, Guava, Lemon, Cream

$15
Christmas In July

Plantation 3 Star Rum, Amaro di Angostura, Allspice Dram, Housemade Orgeat, Lime

$15

Miller Light

4.2% ABV

$6
Yuengling Lager

4.4% ABV

$7
Bonehook "Wicked Seas" Hazy IPA

6.8% ABV

$8
Fort Myers "Gateway Gold" Blonde Ale

$7
Michelob Ultra

4.2% ABV

$5
Stella Artois

5% ABV

$6
Barrel of Monks "Wizard" Witbier

$7
Islamorada "No Wake Zone" Ale

$7
Keewaydin Crusher Cream Ale

$6
Fort Myers Brewing Chocolate Peanut Butter Porter

$8
Omission Gluten-Free Lager

$7
Beck’s Non-Alcoholic

$5

Angels Envy

$24
Basil Hayden Carib RSV

$14
Clyde Mays

$11
High West Double Rye

$11
Kentucky Owl Rye #2

$48
Mastersons 10 yr. Rye

$20
Michters Single Barrel

$12
Redemption

$10
Sazerac Rye

$10
Thomas Handy Rye

$54
Whistlepig "Piggyback"

$11
Whistlepig 10 yr.

$22
Whistlepig 12 yr.

$32
Whistlepig 15 yr.

$50
Whistlepig “Bosshog”

$125

1792 Full Proof

$16
1972 Single Barrel

$14
1972 Small Batch

$12
Angel’s Envy

$14
Basil Hayden’s

$14
Blanton’s

$45
Buffalo Trace

$10
Calumet Farms

$14
Chicken Cock KY Straight

$16
Eagle Rare

$15
Elijah Craig

$13
Elmer T. Lee

$65
E.H. Taylor Small Batch

$13
E.H. Taylor Single Barrel

$22
E.H. Taylor Four Grains

$45
Four Roses Small Batch

$11
Garrison Brothers

$18
Garrison Bros. Single Barrel

$26
High West American Prairie

$11
Maker’s Mark

$11
Maker’s Mark 46

$15
Old Ezra 7 Year

$16
Old Rip Van Winkle 10yr.

$65
George T Stagg

$85
Stagg JR

$35
Wild Turkey “Longbranch”

$11
Wild Turkey Master’s Keep

$39
Wilderness Trail Single Barrel

$20
Wilderness Trail Small Batch

$20
Woodford Reserve

$12
Yellow Stone Ltd KY

$26

Roasted Heirloom Tomato

$11
Smoked Chicken

roasted pear, pickled shallot, gorgonzola, baby arugula, saba

$18
Short Rib

mozzarella, watercress

$18

Pei Mussels

coconut curry, caramelized tomato and onion, toasted baguette

$16
Chicken Marsala Meatballs

Joyce Farms chicken, parmesan, bacon, wild mushrooms

$15
Artisanal Cheese

local honey, fruit compote, toasted baguette

$20
Charcuterie

whole grain mustard, cornichon, toasted baguette

$20
Custom Cheese & Charcuterie

Build your own board exactly how you want it
Artisanal Cheese & Charcuterie

$30

Menus

DAILY SPECIALS

FOR THE TABLE

STARTERS

SALAD

MAINS

SIDES

Sparkling

White Wines

Rosé Wines

Red Wines

Drinks

Bites

CAVE FAVORITES

SEASONAL FEATURES

Bottle / Can

Rye Whiskey

Bourbon

Flatbreads

Soup & Salad

Menus

DAILY SPECIALS

FOR THE TABLE

STARTERS

SALAD

MAINS

SIDES

Sparkling

White Wines

Rosé Wines

Red Wines

Drinks

Bites

CAVE FAVORITES

SEASONAL FEATURES

Bottle / Can

Rye Whiskey

Bourbon

Flatbreads

Soup & Salad

Email Signup

Reservations